Jury Deliberations Begin In Trial Of Ex-Bell Official Angela Spaccia
LOS ANGELES (CBS/AP) — A jury Friday began deliberating the case of Angela Spaccia, former assistant city manager from the tiny city of Bell, whose attorney said in closing arguments that her salary was “staggering” but not criminal.
Attorney Harland Braun said Spaccia may have exercised poor judgment in accepting compensation from the city that soared to $564,000 at its peak.
“I’ve told you I find the amounts of money here are staggering,” Braun said during his closing arguments that ended Thursday. “But where is the crime?” Braun said. “It’s not a crime to take a lawful benefit, even if it’s outrageous.”
He asked jurors, “If someone offered you two or three times what you are making, wouldn’t you take it? He then cited salaries of actors and athletes.
“What is someone worth?” he asked. “What is anyone worth?”
A brief prosecution rebuttal argument took place Friday morning before the case was handed to the jury. Spaccia faces 13 counts of misappropriation of public funds, conflict of interest and other charges.
Braun on Thursday pointed to Spaccia’s boss, former City Manager Robert Rizzo, as the real culprit in the Bell scandal and disclosed to jurors, who had not been told previously, that Rizzo had made a plea deal.
“Where is Rizzo?” he asked repeatedly, suggesting prosecutors should have called him as a witness.
Braun described Rizzo as a gifted city manager who made great changes in Bell until he became greedy and dictatorial.
“There were no checks and balances, and he became a law unto himself,” he said.
Braun said Rizzo was the only one who could approve contracts and Spaccia had no power to override his orders. He denied that she wrote her own employment contracts, a conflict of interest.
“In order to misappropriate funds, you have to have the authority to appropriate,” he said.
Braun spoke after Deputy District Attorney Max Huntsman concluded his final argument, accusing Spaccia and Rizzo of milking the “cash cow” of the small city of Bell.
Huntsman accused Spaccia of doing an “audition” for her job as assistant city manager by showing Rizzo how he could collect 100 percent of his huge salary in retirement.
“That’s how she got her foot in the door,” the prosecutor said of her hiring in 2003, the beginning of her seven-year tenure in which she and Rizzo saw their salaries soar.
By the time they were fired in 2010, Rizzo was receiving an annual salary and benefits package worth $1.18 million and Spaccia was getting $564,000. Their salaries were higher than that of the president of the United States for running the tiny, blue-collar suburb where many of the 35,000 residents live below the federal poverty line.
“They had worked out a very nice retirement program,” Huntsman said. “They didn’t need to work. But they didn’t want to walk away from this cash cow.”
(TM and © Copyright 2013 CBS Local Media, a division of CBS Radio Inc. and its relevant subsidiaries. CBS RADIO and EYE Logo TM and Copyright 2013 CBS Broadcasting Inc. Used under license. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.)