Students Look To 2012 After Immigration Bill Fails

LOS ANGELES (AP) — Emboldened by months of phone calls to lawmakers, hunger strikes and sit-ins, a group of college students and graduates in Los Angeles say they plan to take their fight for immigrant rights to the states and the 2012 election after Senate Republicans blocked a key piece of legislation.

But it won’t be easy.

The Senate vote Saturday to toss the proposal that would have granted young illegal immigrants a route to legal status dealt a harsh blow to student activists who will face an even steeper uphill battle in the next Congress.

Immigrants see rough times ahead in the next two years, with many Republicans vowing to push for tougher immigration enforcement, but they also say Latino voters are getting fed up with lawmakers at a time when they are accruing greater political clout.

“This is a movement,” said Nancy Meza, a 23-year-old illegal immigrant and college graduate who wore a University of California, Los Angeles sweatshirt as she watched the televised vote. “We don’t have lobbyists and paid staff. It’s a movement by students.”

In the hours after the vote, Meza and about 50 other student activists who had gathered at the UCLA Downtown Labor Center said they would remind Latinos who stood by them — and those who did not — in the next election cycle. They will push for access to financial aid and drivers’ licenses in states more friendly to immigrants like California.

Few said the legislation, many called the Dream Act, had a chance in the next two years with Republicans taking control of the House of Representatives and a shrinking Democratic majority in the Senate. But they said that wouldn’t derail the networks they had set up across the country to support illegal immigrant students and help them reveal their status and learn to live unafraid.

Some at the UCLA center, including university student Leslie Perez, 22, wept as they watched the vote on a big screen.

Minutes after it was over, many donned jackets and umbrellas to take to the rainy streets of Los Angeles, chanting “undocumented and unafraid.”

Republicans might consider some kind of measure to help the students, but it would probably be much narrower, said Mark Krikorian, executive director of the Center for Immigration Studies, which advocates stricter limits on immigration.

“This has a real demoralizing effect,” Krikorian said of the student activists. “There’s only so long you can keep up these hunger strikes and all this political theater they’ve been engaging in, especially if there’s no specific target.”

Another challenge is students could wind up feeling excluded when they can’t work after graduation, despite their political activism.

“It may alienate the group we most want to incorporate,” said Louis DeSipio, a professor of political science at University of California, Irvine.
Immigrant rights groups said they planned to turn up the pressure on the Obama administration to slow deportations, end local police enforcement of immigration laws and look out for the students, many of whom publicly revealed their immigration status over the last few months.

Students also said they planned to fight for immigrant benefits — though it’s not legalization — locally as they’ve seen anti-illegal immigration activists do to pass tougher enforcement measures in states like Arizona.

“They’re winning by state, they’re winning by region,” said Cyndi Bendezu, a 25-year-old University of California, Los Angeles graduate who was brought to the United States from Peru when she was 4 years old. “We have to win smaller victories.”

Bendezu, who had been an illegal immigrant when she started college, attained legal residency through a relative’s petition. Now, she said she can’t wait to become a citizen to be able to vote.

Students said Saturday that momentum they had gained in recent months was bigger than the legislative defeat.

The legislation would have provided a route to legal status for immigrants who were brought to the United States before age 16, have lived in the country for five years, graduated from high school or gained an equivalency degree and who joined the military or attend college.

It targeted the most sympathetic of the 10 million to 12 million illegal immigrants living in the United States — those brought to the country as children, and who in many cases consider themselves American, speak English and have no ties to their native countries.

Critics of the bill called it a backdoor to amnesty that would encourage more foreigners to sneak into the United States in hopes of being legalized eventually.

The Mexican-born Meza said the vote makes it harder for her to finance graduate school to get a doctorate in education policy and become a professor.

But Meza, who came to the country when she was 2, said she’ll find a way — just as she did baby-sitting, tutoring and waiting tables to pay for college even though her degree now lies covered in dust in her living room, unused.

“It’s not going to stop my educational goals,” she said.

The legislation was proposed almost a decade ago. But it got its closest shot at getting passed this year after students stepped up their activism by making thousands of calls to lawmakers and leading marches and demonstrations. Several activists were arrested for refusing to leave Arizona Sen. John McCain’s office.

The House of Representatives passed the measure earlier this month, but the Senate fell five votes short of the 60 needed to win its enactment.

Now, immigrant advocates who had touted the bill as a first push toward a broader legalization of immigrants will be working to deflect anticipated efforts by Republicans to ramp up restrictions on immigration.

“All of us are definitely preparing for much more defensive work,” said Marielena Hincapie, executive director of the National Immigration Law Center.

(© Copyright 2010 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)

  • Kellie R.

    How about we help fix the Californian/National financial crisis first, then fix the outrageous student loan bubble that’s ready to burst, clean up the pathetic educational system, and then we concentrate on immigration rights?

  • Rob

    Illegal immigrant students have a path to citizenship, it’s called the U.S. military.

  • Charlie

    You haven’t seen anything yet,once the GOP takes over next month,you will see army troops rounding up Latinos in every city across the US and millions and millions of them forcefully marching toward the Mexican border,escorted by our patriotic Minutemen,with the authority to shoot to kill if any of them tries to escape.Finally Erica just for us.Long live the GOP.

    • alan hart

      A nice thought but it won’t happen

    • Duh!

      So Charlie, you think it is okay to let criminals live among us and do as they please?

  • Clara Morrison

    How is it a “right” to be granted citizenship when you came here illegally?
    Has anyone noticed the US is in a financial crisis and we can’t take care of our own citizens? Why should we be forced to use tax dollars for those who are here illegally?
    Did you know that 86% of illegal immigrants will qualify for the health care subsidies under the new health care law if they are granted citizenship? Do you want your tax dollars to pay for that?
    Did you know that under the DREAM act, illegal immigrants who have been convicted of misdemeanors (including sexual assault and driving under the influence) would be eligible for citizenship?
    Did you know that, once they are granted citizenship under the DREAM act, these illegal immigrants would be able to sponsor their entire families to stay in the US–at taxpayer expense?
    Are you willing for your taxes to go up to support people who are here illegally? Are you willing to get less in Social Security in order for those who came here illegally (and did not pay into the system) to be able to draw Social Security?

  • Jose

    How about a big “Thank You!” for the stolen education!

    How about immediately deporting these people as the law mandates if they are not happy with receiving citizen funded benefits?

    How about American citizen rights to have borders protected and enforced?

    How about ending “birth tourism” whereby pregnant females come here to give birth to cheat our immigration system?

  • Brian

    hell, have the legal students can’t get financial aid in the first place so i think that getting legal students aid comes before illegal students any day

  • D417

    Well said, Kellie! It’s absolutely ridiculous that we support so many who pay NOTHING into the system. They are a burden. It’s time we stop hosting these parasites and take care of the people who pay the taxes. Stop the handouts!! Their parents work tax-free and send the money to mexico.

  • Nuf Said

    Support the initiative to get California’s version of Arizona’s SB 1070 on the ballot. Go to www.

  • Jose S.

    As a Los Angeles born Mexican American to legal parents, if you came to this country illegally, you broke the law, or your parents broke the law. Either case you have NO RIGHTS in my country until you go through the proper immigration system. Either, go cry to your parents or go cry to Mexico because its their fault you are here. Again, those are your problems not mine!!!!!

  • Don Shag Marshall

    Just another reason to make it a law to present proof you are a citizen before voting…

  • Gabriel Hill

    Take the education and go back and fix Mexico please.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Sandwich Generation

Listen Live